APPRAISAL + CONSULTING

Built on experience.

Built on experience.

Westmark provides umpire services, appraisal, building consulting, and insurance adjusting backed by 25 years of hands-on construction experience. Independent judgment. Clear communication. A practical understanding of what the work actually requires.


Westmark provides umpire services, appraisal, building consulting, and insurance adjusting backed by 25 years of hands-on construction experience. Independent judgment. Clear communication. A practical understanding of what the work actually requires.

Explore Our Services

Licensed contractor since 1987

Licensed contractor, 30 years

25 years as an independent contractor

Independent contractor, 25 years

Serving California, Oregon, and Washington

California, Oregon, Washington

CONSTRUCTION-INFORMED JUDGMENT

A better evaluation starts with understanding
the work.

A better evaluation starts with understanding
the work.

A better evaluation starts with understanding
the work.

Property claims often come down to scope, pricing, repair methods, and what it will actually take to restore a building. David Dawson spent 25 years working as an independent contractor before bringing that experience into insurance claims, appraisal, consulting, and dispute resolution. He understands the estimate. More importantly, he understands the work behind every line item.

Practical building knowledge

A working understanding of building systems, materials, labor, project sequencing, and repair methods.

Independent evaluation

Each assignment is reviewed on its own facts, documentation, observed conditions, and defined scope.

Clear communication

Straightforward findings that help the people involved understand what is supported, what remains disputed, and what happens next.

What we do

Four services. One standard.

Four services. One standard.

Every assignment is approached with careful review, practical judgment, and respect for the role Westmark has been asked to perform.

Umpire Services

When appointed appraisers cannot resolve their differences, Westmark can serve as umpire to review the remaining issues and provide an independent determination. We evaluate the documentation, estimates, inspection findings, and positions presented by both appraisers. Our role is to address the disputed amount-of-loss issues with impartiality, construction knowledge, and sound professional judgment.

Request Umpire Services →

Appraisal Services

Westmark provides property insurance appraisal services when the amount of loss is disputed. The work may include property inspection, document review, scope analysis, estimating, pricing evaluation, and communication with the other appointed appraiser. The result is a clear, well-supported appraisal position grounded in the property and the work required.


Westmark provides property insurance appraisal services when the amount of loss is disputed. The work may include property inspection, document review, scope analysis, estimating, pricing evaluation, and communication with the other appointed appraiser. The result is a clear, well-supported appraisal position grounded in the property and the work required.

Request Appraisal Services →

Building Consulting

Some claims require a deeper understanding of how the building was constructed, damaged, and should be repaired. Westmark provides construction-informed review of:

Repair scope

Building systems

Repair methods

Project sequencing

Estimates and pricing

Contractor documentation

Damage-related building questions

The goal is simple: bring practical building knowledge to decisions that should not be made from paperwork alone.

Discuss a Building Matter →

Insurance Adjusting

Westmark provides independent property adjusting support, including:

Property inspection

Damage documentation

Scope development

Estimating

File review

Clear written reporting

Claim coordination

Each assignment is handled with attention to the property, the documentation, and the requirements of the client.

Request Adjusting Support →

APPRAISER OR UMPIRE?

APPRAISER OR UMPIRE?

Different assignments require different judgment.

Different assignments require different judgment.

Different assignments require different judgment.

When serving as an appraiser

When serving as an appraiser

David is appointed by one party to independently evaluate the disputed amount of loss. He develops a well-supported position, communicates with the opposing appraiser, and works toward agreement on the disputed scope and value.


David is appointed by one party to independently evaluate the disputed amount of loss. He develops a well-supported position, communicates with the opposing appraiser, and works toward agreement on the disputed scope and value.


When serving as an umpire

When serving as an umpire

David is selected to address differences the two appointed appraisers have been unable to resolve. He reviews the disputed items and supporting information, hears both positions, and makes an independent determination within the appraisal assignment. In either role, the standard remains the same: understand the property, review the evidence, and support the conclusion.

David is selected to address differences the two appointed appraisers have been unable to resolve. He reviews the disputed items and supporting information, hears both positions, and makes an independent determination within the appraisal assignment. In either role, the standard remains the same: understand the property, review the evidence, and support the conclusion.

WHY WESTMARK

Experience matters when the details matter.

Experience matters when the details matter.

Experience matters when the details matter.

David Dawson has held a contractor’s license since 1987 and spent 25 years operating as an independent contractor. That career gave him direct experience with how buildings are designed, constructed, repaired, priced, and maintained. It also taught him where estimates can miss real-world conditions and how one repair decision can affect the rest of a project. Today, David applies that experience to property claims and disputes throughout California, Oregon, and Washington.


The difference is practical understanding.

The difference is practical understanding.

The difference is practical understanding.

A written estimate can look complete while missing the work required to perform the repair. Materials must be removed and replaced in the right order. Building systems affect one another. Access, code requirements, site conditions, labor, and finish matching can all change the real scope of a project. Construction experience helps Westmark identify those relationships and evaluate the claim as a complete building problem, not a collection of disconnected line items.


Construction knowledge. Independent judgment. Clear conclusions.

Construction knowledge. Independent judgment. Clear conclusions.

Construction knowledge. Independent judgment. Clear conclusions.

WHY WESTMARK

A clear process from assignment to resolution.

A clear process from assignment to resolution.

A clear process from assignment to resolution.

01

01

Submit the assignment

Submit the assignment

Provide the property location, claim number, date of loss, requested service, and a short description of the matter. Include available estimates, photographs, reports, correspondence, or other supporting documents.

02

02

Confirm the role and scope

Confirm the role and scope

Westmark reviews the assignment, confirms availability, checks for conflicts, and identifies any additional information needed to begin.

03

03

Review and inspect

Review and inspect

David reviews the submitted materials and performs a property inspection when required by the assignment. The evaluation may include observed damage, repair scope, pricing, repair methods, documentation, and the disputed positions.

04

04

Evaluate and communicate

Evaluate and communicate

Westmark organizes the relevant findings, communicates with the appropriate parties, and works through the issues within the defined assignment.

05

05

Deliver the work

Deliver the work

Depending on the service, the final work may include an estimate, appraisal position, written report, consulting opinion, adjustment documentation, or umpire determination.

WHO WE WORK WITH

Experienced support for the people responsible for moving claims forward.

Experienced support for the people responsible for moving claims forward.

Experienced support for the people responsible for moving claims forward.

Westmark accepts assignments from professionals and parties involved in property claims and disputes, including:

Insurance carriers and claims organizations

Independent adjusters

Appraisers and umpires

Insurance carriers and claims organizations

Independent adjusters

Appraisers and umpires

Attorneys and legal teams

Property owners and their representatives

Contractors and construction professionals

Attorneys and legal teams

Property owners and their representatives

Contractors and construction professionals

All assignments are subject to role clarity, availability, and conflict review.

CALIFORNIA · OREGON · WASHINGTON

One practice serving the West Coast.

One practice serving the West Coast.

One practice serving the West Coast.

Westmark provides appraisal and consulting services throughout California, Oregon, and Washington. Assignment availability depends on property location, timing, service requirements, and the complexity of the matter. For work outside the primary service area, contact Westmark to discuss the assignment.


Frequently asked questions

Frequently asked questions

Frequently asked questions

When should I contact Westmark?

When should I contact Westmark?

Contact Westmark when a property claim requires appraisal, umpire services, construction review, or independent adjusting support. Early contact is especially helpful when the dispute involves scope, pricing, repair methodology, or conflicting estimates.

What information should I provide?

What information should I provide?

Please include:

Your name and organization

Requested service

Property address

Claim number

Date of loss

Names of the parties involved

A short description of the matter

Relevant estimates, reports, photographs, or other documents

Can Westmark serve as either appraiser or umpire?

Can Westmark serve as either appraiser or umpire?

Yes. David can be considered for either role, depending on the assignment, existing appointments, conflicts, and availability.

Does Westmark make insurance coverage decisions?

Does Westmark make insurance coverage decisions?

Westmark’s work is focused on the property, the assigned valuation or construction issues, and the specific role defined by the engagement. Insurance coverage and legal questions remain with the appropriate carriers, parties, and legal professionals.

What types of properties does Westmark handle?

What types of properties does Westmark handle?

Westmark considers residential, commercial, and other property-related assignments based on the location, scope, and technical requirements of the matter.Contact Westmark with the property details to confirm fit and availability.

START AN ASSIGNMENT

Bring the claim into clearer focus.

Bring the claim into clearer focus.

Bring the claim into clearer focus.

Tell us where the property is, what role you need, and where the matter currently stands. Westmark will review the information and respond with availability and next steps.

Umpire Services | Appraisal | Building Consulting | Insurance Adjusting

Serving California, Oregon, and Washington

805-630-1676 | david@westmarkappraisal.com

CA License 2F05666 | OR License 7493051 | TX License 1202991 | CSLB 553906, 795170

© 2026 Westmark Appraisal & Consulting. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy